Friday 29 March 2013

Yellow or not?


What came first: the chicken or the egg? The same question can arise for colour names. ‘Yellow’, for example. In Ancient Egyptian, was there a word for ‘yellow’ or did things that happened to be yellow in colour have a common root?

Faulkner provides a start:

word
meaning
EngJSM
source
page/line
glyphs
(ḳny: qeni)
"be yellow"
yellow 
Faulkner Concise
[280:6]
<slope water reeds EGG-ears: pour>


qeni: ‘be yellow’


(ḳnỉt: qeni-t)
"a yellow pigment"
yellow what is 
Faulkner Concise
[280:4]
<slope water reed bun ring PLURAL>
(ḳnỉt: qeni-t)
"yellowness"
yellow what is 
Faulkner Concise
[280:5]
<slope water reed bun eye>
(ḳnt: qen-et)
"yellowness"
yellow what is 
Faulkner Concise
[279:6]
<slope water bun tallhorns>


Looking at the root ‘qen’ offers some insights, and inevitably some distractions. The insights first:

‘Yellow’ insights

(ḳn: qeni)
"sheaf"
sheaf  
Faulkner Concise
[279:16]
<slope water reed magnet: bar>
(ḳn: qeni)
"sheaf"
sheaf  
Faulkner Concise
[279:16]
<slope water reed magnet: bar>
(ḳn: qen)
"mat"
mat  
Faulkner Concise
[279:14.1]
<fence water grid>
(ḳn: qen)
"mat"
mat  
Gardiner
[596.2:5]
<fence water MAGNET: bar>
(ḳn: qeni)
"ceremonial garment"
garment  ceremonial
Faulkner Concise
[279:15]
<slope water reed U-rope>
(ḳni: qeni)
"palanquin"
  
Gardiner
[620.2:7]
<slope water reed magnet: bar>
(ḳnỉw: qeniyu)
"portable shrine"

Faulkner Concise
[280:3]
<slope water reed quail temple: basin>


A sheaf of wheat might have been seen as a yellow object. A rush mat might equally have been yellow. And what colour might the ceremonial garment have been, or the palanquin, given these ideas? There might be a connection between palanquin and portable shrine, and perhaps the next group might offer a suggestion: one might need to be strong to carry either.

No connection with ‘yellow’

word
meaning
EngJSM
source
page/line
glyphs
(ḳni: qeni)
"embrace"
hug  
Gardiner
[596.2:6]
<slope water reed arms: down>
(qnj: qeni)
"embrace"
hug  
Allen
[469.2:8]
<slope water reed arms: down>
(ḳn: qeni)
"brave"
strong  
Faulkner Concise
[279:7]
<slope water stander: stick>
(qnj: qeni)
"diligent"
strong  
Allen
[469.2:5]
<slope water stander: stick>
(qn: qen)
"audacity"
strong  bravery
Allen
[469.2:6]
<slope water CROSS-X>
(ḳn: qen)
"strong"
strong  
Gardiner
[596.2:3]
<slope water stander: stick>
(ḳn: qen)
"fat"
plump  
Faulkner Concise
[279:5]
<slope water tallhorns>
(ḳn: qen)
"complete"
complete  
Gardiner
[596.2:4]
<fence water PLANE>
(ḳn: qen)
"complete"
complete  
Faulkner Concise
[279:13]
<fence water PLANE-v>
(ḳn: qen)
"offence"
offence  
Faulkner Concise
[279:12]
<slope water sparrow>
(ḳnḳnyt: qen qenit)
"mallet"

Faulkner Concise
[280:13]
<slope water slope water reeds bun branch>
(ḳnḳn: qen qen)
"beat"
beat 
Faulkner Concise
[280:12]
<slope water slope water cross-X arm: stick>


In this second group the main idea might be ‘strong’. Coupled with the idea of ‘big’ and ‘power’ and its exercising, one can group hug, beat, mallet, and offence together, as well as plump (big). Complete seems to be another idea. None of these suggest a link to yellow.

Jeremy Steele
Friday 29 March 2013
=================

Sunday 17 March 2013

What is: the hieroglyphic nominaliser -et


PERSONAL DECLARATION: I am neither a scholar nor an expert in Ancient Egyptian or hieroglyphs. Rather I am an amateur taking an interest in the language and its writing.
The views expressed are my own, and for the reasons just stated could be erroneous.

The suffix -(e)t

A very common suffix in Ancient Egyptian (AE) is  -(e)t. It has at least two functions.

1. Feminine marker

First, as a marker indicating a feminine form:


miyu: cat
mit: cat, female


bun in the above example on the right is the feminine (/t/) marker.

2. Nominaliser

Second, -et may convert a word into a noun.

The scholarly books to which I have access do not for the most part say much about this.

Gardiner
§48.4 (p.47) allocates three lines in a paragraph on adjectives used as nouns to this suffix. He does not enunciate the suffixing principle, but rather gives feminine examples featuring it:
neferet: ‘beautiful woman’
neferet: ‘beautiful cow”
Gardiner's paragraph is mainly about the determinative showing the difference between to the two words (woman in one case, cow in the other).
This is part of three lines, in a work of 646 pages.
-----
Gardiner, Sir Alan Henderson. 1957 (2007). Egyptian Grammar: being an introduction to the study of hieroglyphs. 3rd ed., rev. ed. Oxford: Griffith Institute, Ashmolean Museum, Oxford, by Oxford University Press.

-----

Allen
(Middle Egyptian), in over 500 pages, states on p. 61:
The feminine singular adjective nfrt, for instance, can be used by itself  to refer to any “good,” “beautiful,” or “perfect” person or thing: for example nfrt “the beautiful woman,” or nfrt “a good thing.”

And that is all.
-----
Allen, James P. 2000, 2001. Middle Egyptian: an introduction to the language and culture of hieroglyphs. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

-----

Collier/Manley
Fortunately Collier/Manley are more helpful, at pages 69, 94 and 147. At p. 69:
“... ‘what I did myself’ is expressed by using another verb-form — the past relative form: irt.n(=i). In this usage, there is no separate word for  ‘what’ or ‘which’, rather the verb-form shows a -t in its writing, so irt.n (=i) in itself means ‘what I did’ without needing extra words.”

On page 147 they provide four related pairs of examples, in the present and past tense. Two are:
sdmt=f: ‘what he hears’
(sdmt=f: sedjem-et-ef) "hearing he: what" hear what he Col/Man [147:13] <ear: ox owl bun viper>

rdit.n=f: what he gave
(rdit.n=f: redi-t-en-ef) "give (past) he: what" give what did he Col/Man [147:20] <mouth arm: TEEPEE bun viper bun water viper>

[The key portions (/t/ and 'what' have been identified in bold type in this entry.]
-----
Collier, Mark, and Bill Manley. 1998. How to read Egyptian hieroglyphs: a step by step guide to teach yourself. London: British Museum Press.

-----

Finding the -(e)t suffix, and noting its significance
Equipped with Collier/Manley's  information, we can now see that the AEs made prolific use of the technique, with illuminating results. For example, 
djeret: hand


transcription / respelling
translation
EngJSM
source
glyph sequence
(drt: djeret) 
"hand"
hand  
Gardiner [614.2:9.2]
<skip: bow mouth bun hand: cupped>
(drt: djeret) 
"Hand"
hand  
Nureldin [218:33.2]
<hand bun stroke>
(drt: djeret) 
"hand"
hand  
Allen [472.1:9]
<hand bun stroke>
(drt: djeret) 
"hand"
hand  
Faulkner Concise [323:3]
<hand bun STROKE>

Nedj Nedj Databases
The examples, and the graphics above, quoted in this entry are taken from the Nedj Nedj Databases.
For more on these databases see <nedjnedjhieroglyphs.blogspot.com>.

As this word is suffixed in -et, does it have a root of interest?

djer: end

(dr: djer) 
"end"
end  
Gardiner [617.1:37]
<skip: bow mouth road>
(dr: djer) 
"end up"
end  
Allen [472.1:7]
<skip: bow mouth>
(dr: djer) 
"end"
end  
Faulkner Concise [323:6]
<skip: bow mouth stander: stick>


djer-et, consequently, would appear literally to mean: ‘what is at the end’, and what is at the end of one’s arm if not one’s hand?

An alternative meaning for djer-et is 'the trunk of an elephant', a feature the end of which might be in the mind of a beholder.

Other -(e)t examples are:

transcription / respelling
translation
EngJSM
source
glyph sequence
(bnrt: bener-et
"sweetness"
sweet what is 
Faulkner Concise [83:8.1]
<leg water mouth reed bun pod: sunrise>
(bint: bin-et
"evil"
bad what is 
Col/Man [94:4]
<leg reed water bun sparrow>
(dmdt: demedj-et
"collection"
assemble what is 
Faulkner Concise [313:11]
<flails: ten hand bun twist STROKE>
(dšrt: desher-et
"wrath"
anger what is 
Faulkner Concise [316:12]
<hand pool mouth bun diagonal>
(dšrt: desher-et
"desert"
red what is 
Gardiner [610.1:36.1]
<flamingo mouth bun hills>
(ḥ3qt: HAq-et
"plunder"
capture what is [goods]
Allen [463.1:9]
<pap eagle slope bun arm: stick PLURAL>
(ḥnskt: Henesek-et
"braided lock"
tie what is 
Faulkner Concise [173:3]
<rope herb: hn water bolt cup bun hair>
(ỉmnt: imen-et
"secret"
hide what is 
Faulkner Concise [21:5]
<reed comb water bun kneeler: praise>
(ỉmntt: imenet-et
"West"
west what is 
Faulkner Concise [21:12.1]
<feather: bun&cloth bunx2 hills>
(ỉntt: inetj-et
"fetter"
fetter what is 
Faulkner Concise [24:13.1]
<reed water tether bun unwind>
(ỉ3btt: iyabet-et
"East"
east what is 
Faulkner Concise [8:17.1]
<telegraph leg bunx2 hills>
(hnmt: khenem-et
"joined (with)"
join what is 
Col/Man [29:19]
<jug bun>
(mdt: medj-et
"depth"
deep what is 
Faulkner Concise [123:5.1]
<owl cobra-J bun magnet: bar rails STROKE>
(nbt: neb-et
"every"
all what is every
Gardiner [573.2:2.2]
<basin bun>
(ne'teset: nedjes-et
"little"
little what is 
EAWB [189:8.6]
<sparrow bun>
(nḫnt: nekhen-et
"childhood"
young what is 
Gardiner [575.2:3.2]
<water string water bun child>
(snnt: senen-et
"likeness"
likeness what is 
Faulkner Concise [232:14]
<cloth rushx2 waterx2 bun>
(stt: set-et
"spearing"
pierce what is 
Col/Man [14:8]
<cloth bunx2 target: arrows>
(sỉnt: sin-et
"clay seal"
 what is ......
Faulkner Concise [213:2]
<cloth reed fish: fatfin water bun PLURAL>
(t3rt: tjAr-et
"cabin"
secure what is [cabin]
Faulkner Concise [303:16]
<duckling eagle mouth bun magnet: ears house>
(wrt: wer-et
"greatly"
big what is 
Allen [457.1:22]
<swallow mouth bun>



Consider the root verb for a few of these:


(bnr: bener) 
"sweet"
sweet  
Col/Man [137:28]
<tassel>
(bin: bin) 
"evil"
bad  
Col/Man [154.1:4]
<leg reed water sparrow>
(dmd: demedj) 
"total"
total  
Gardiner [627.1:32]
<flails: ten hand PLANE>
(dšr: desher) 
"red"
red  
Gardiner [603.1:6]
<hand pool mouth flamingo>
(nḫn: nekhen) 
"young"
young  
Gardiner [575.2:3.1]
<water string water child>
(t3r: tjAr) 
"fasten"
secure  
Gardiner [601.1:15.1]
<duckling eagle mouth MAGNET: ears>


bener: ‘sweet’ bener-et: ‘what is sweet’ (sweetness)
demedj: ‘total’ demedj-et: ‘what is assembled’
desher: ‘red’ desher-et: ‘what is red’ (the desert, ‘Red Land’, even ‘wrath‘ — red-in-the-face)
nekhen: ‘young’ nekhen-et: ‘what is young’ (childhood)
tjAr:’fasten’ tjAr-et: ‘what is secure / safe’ (cabin)

-------------

So what about the sin-et  ‘clay seal’ example above?

There are several possibilities.


transcription / respelling
translation
EngJSM
source
glyph sequence
(zjn: sin) 
"rub"
  
Allen [465.2:27]
<bolt fish: fatfin water arm: stick>
(sỉn: sin) 
"rub"
  
Faulkner Concise [213:4.11]
<bolt reed water arm>
(sỉn: sin) 
"clay"
  
Faulkner Concise [213:1]
<cloth reed water egg: ears rails>
(sỉn: sin) 
"rub out"
  
Faulkner Concise [213:4.21]
<bolt fish: fatfin water>
(sỉn: sin) 
"pass away"
  
Faulkner Concise [213:7.21]
<cloth reed water egg: ears legs>
(sin: sin) 
"smear"
  
Gardiner [588.2:11]
<cloth reed fish: fatfin water arm>



As sin means ‘rub’, ‘rub out’, ‘smear’, ‘clay’ and ‘pass away’ (die), sin-et might refer to something that is rubbed, rubbed out, smeared, or made of clay. All of these could apply to ‘clay seal’. Or the clay seal might be connected to ‘passing away‘ — sealing up a canopic jar, perhaps.

Conclusion
For such a richly rewarding suffix as -et, it is a surprise that is has been accorded slight attention by the major grammarians.